Social Security at Risk – Bad news for American Retirees

Retirement is a dream most workers chase across the globe, but not all pension systems are created equal. The Mercer CFA 2024 Global Pension Index sheds light on this disparity. Unfortunately, the U.S. ranked 29th out of 48 countries, receiving a C+ grade. While the U.S. retirement system offers some benefits, the report warns of critical risks and shortcomings that need urgent attention.

Interestingly, the U.S. score dropped from 63 to 60.4 since last year, emphasizing the growing challenges for its retirement framework. The report evaluated retirement systems based on three key pillars: adequacy, sustainability, and integrity. So, what caused the U.S. to slip in the rankings, and what lessons can we take from top-ranked countries? Let’s look in.

Adequacy

Adequacy focuses on how well a system supports retirees with sufficient income for their later years. While Social Security provides a basic safety net in the U.S., it wasn’t designed to cover all retirement needs. Rising costs of living, inflation, and the shift toward individual savings plans (like 401(k)s) mean many Americans struggle to save enough.

Experts argue that U.S. retirees face gaps in both financial literacy and savings. According to Einat Steklov, co-founder of Kashable, the U.S. system lacks adequate accessibility and education. These gaps leave individuals responsible for making investment decisions that were once managed by corporations or professionals.

Sustainability

Sustainability looks at whether a pension system can continue functioning as populations age. This involves monitoring public pension spending, government debt, and the old-age dependency ratio—the balance between workers and retirees.

The U.S. faces headwinds in this area, given its aging population and the growing strain on Social Security. Without reform, the sustainability of the current system is questionable. In contrast, countries like the Netherlands and Iceland earned high marks for balancing generous benefits with long-term sustainability.

Integrity

Integrity focuses on how well a system is governed and whether it provides clear information to members. Transparent rules and strong regulation ensure people can make informed decisions about their pensions.

The Mercer CFA report noted that the U.S. struggles to provide such clarity, especially for private savings plans. This contributes to the complexity of retirement planning, making it difficult for many individuals to navigate the system effectively.

Top-Ranked Countries

The 2024 report highlights the Netherlands, Iceland, Denmark, and Israel as countries with superior retirement systems. These nations combine robust public pensions with incentives for private savings, ensuring both adequacy and sustainability. Brandy Burch, CEO of Benefitbay, noted that in the U.S., Social Security alone isn’t enough—enhancing or expanding its benefits would significantly boost retirement security.

Burch also pointed out that while 401(k) plans and IRAs offer flexibility, access is uneven. Many workers, especially those without employer-sponsored plans, are left behind. She suggests extending these opportunities to more people to level the playing field.

Shifting Trends

Interestingly, even the Netherlands—the gold standard in retirement systems—is shifting from collective benefits to individual defined contribution (DC) plans, similar to the U.S. While this shift offers flexibility, it also transfers more responsibility to individuals, which can be challenging without sufficient financial knowledge and tools.

In the U.S., the rise of automatic enrollment and employer matching contributions has encouraged more people to save, but more support is needed to ensure everyone has access to secure retirement options.

The Mercer CFA report serves as both a warning and an opportunity. While the U.S. has made strides with private savings plans, its public system needs reform to remain effective and sustainable. Expanding Social Security or offering more savings options beyond the workplace could be game-changers for millions of Americans.

FAQs